EPages Sizemore: Moviedrome

Last Updated: 08 March 2002

The Big Silence (Il Grande Silenzio)

Italy 1969

Director Sergio Corbucci
Written by Sergio Corbucci, Petrilli Amendola, B Corbucci
With Jean-Louis Trintignant, Frank Wolff, Klaus Kinski. Luigi Pistilli, Mario Brega, Vonetta McGee

Sergio Corbucci was also the director of the cult western Django, which was banned in Britain for many years. Although The Big Silence is his best film, it has never been shown publicly here or in the United States. It's easy to see why. The film, like most Italian westerns is incredibly bleak and pessimistic, but worse, it has the most horrible ending of any film I've ever seen. It was considered so strong that the producers asked Corbucci to shoot another. Apparently, that version played in certain Middle Eastern countries, where action films are popular but they have to have a happy ending.
There was another reason for the film's suppression, though. When it came out in 1969, The Big Silence was extremely popular in Italy and Germany and especially in France. It stars the French actor Jean-Louis Trintignant as 'Silence', a mute gunfighter, and there was talk in Europe that Clint Eastwood was going to buy the rights snd recreate the role. But he didn't. What he did do was to take the external trappings of The Big Silence - the snow, the costumes, even the hero's hat and peculiar gun - and put them in a completely boring 1972 cowboy film that he produced called Joe Kidd, directed by Joe Sturges.
The beginning of The Big Silence is a little ragged, but bear with it. Once you're aboard the stagecoach with Trintignant and Klaus Kinski - who plays the politest murderer out west - you're in for an amazing ride. The music is by Ennio Morricone; it's a great and very unusual score.

More from Moviedrome


Home and Email or Contact

Copyright © 2002 Mike Atherton